SIR – Further to David Hornby’s analysis regarding Labour’s fortunes during the recent election, the situation in Scotland was unprecedented, resulting in the loss of 40 seats for the party (Letters, May 12).

The Scottish referendum was the culmination of a historical process, unleashing national sentiments which Labour had little control over.

In England, Labour in opposition would normally have retaken marginals like Pudsey and Keighley, but a fear of a hung parliament and the intemperate tone of the Scottish nationalists encouraged people to vote for the Conservatives. In key marginal seats the Tories were often able to increase their small majorities.

Once all these factors are considered, Labour would probably have gained the most seats, if not an overall majority, but for unusual circumstances.

The discussions whether Labour’s manifesto was excessively to the left or whether Mr Miliband proved a liability to the party are irrelevant when the above is considered. In fact it was widely acknowledged that he conducted himself in a dignified manner and displayed a charm and courtesy which surprised many people.

Alec Suchi, Allerton Road, Bradford