Keighley's film version of the legendary Railway Children story steamed ahead in a New Year poll.

The public signalled its overwhelming preference for the classic 1970 movie over the more recent TV adaptation.

But poll organisers said the general opinion was that neither production should be shunted into the sidings.

The debate was sparked by the screening last month of both the original version -- filmed on the Keighley and Worth Valley Railway -- and the Carlton TV remake which was first shown in April 2000.

The TV version of Edith Nesbit's timeless tale was shot on the Bluebell Railway, in East Sussex.

The K&WVR, which conducted the poll, said there was an overwhelming response.

A spokesman said: "It came as no surprise to find that visitors preferred 'their' 1970 film version to the recent remake.

"Many locals remembered the making of the film and seeing the celebrities here in the valley. Others recalled their involvement as extras and provided many humorous -- but sadly unrepeatable -- anecdotes.

"Although nobody claimed the new version to be superior, many felt both were enjoyable and were prompted to seek out the original book.

"We are grateful to everyone who took the trouble to contact us. I think there is plenty of room for both versions of Edith Nesbit's wonderful story," added the spokesman.