Gary Moorby returns to the scene of his debut mauling as the Cougars take on the Eagles in the Challenge Cup fourth round.
Keighley travel to Sheffield a week on Sunday looking for revenge for two defeats at the Don Valley Stadium last season.
But the game they are most keen to seek vengeance for was the 60-0 hammering that marked Moorby's first day in the job.
Although the Cougars picked up a victory over Sheffield at the back end of last year, they still feel a score needs settling.
"I think we need to set the record straight by taking them on in their back yard," said Moorby after last night's draw.
"It is a bit of a Doncaster situation we face here. They gave us a good hiding last season and then we turned them over last week.
"And we would be looking to do the same to Sheffield."
Although a number of players were keen on the big draw, and no doubt the chairman would have fancied one too, Moorby believes his side has every chance of progressing into the next round.
"It could have been worse," said Moorby, whose side turned over amateur side Thornhill Trojans 33-10 at the weekend to get into the draw.
"It is not the most lucrative of ties. I know they don't get big crowds down at their place, but it is a winnable game.
"A few lads wanted a big tie but we can't be too unhappy with this. I think if we prepare well we could have every chance against them.
"They have made a lot of changes since last year and will probably be fielding quite a young outfit.
"We haven't been in the fifth round of the Challenge Cup for some time, so this will be a big game for the club.
"And hopefully we can get through this and pick up a Super League club next time around."
Last year the Cougars were knocked out 24-0 by French side St Gaudens in the third round.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article