A devoted husband who killed his wife after she begged him to help her die has been convicted of murder.
Retired Bradford accountant Frank Lund, 58, admitted suffocating wife Patricia, 65, with a plastic bag and a pillow at their home last September.
He denied murder on the grounds that Mrs Lund, his wife of 33 years, had persuaded him to help her die after her life was made miserable by an irritable bowel condition. His claims were not contested during a three-day trial at Liverpool Crown Court, in which he was supported by his late wife's relatives, including her son Stephen Olive, of Fagley, Bradford.
But the jury was warned to put sympathy aside and judge the defendant on the facts. They were told by Mr Justice Silber to find Lund guilty of murder if they were satisfied that he deliberately killed her.
The jury took three hours yesterday to return the guilty verdict, at which Lund showed no emotion. His relatives gavemuffled gasps and were thanked by the judge for their "quiet dignified behaviour" during the case.
He remanded Lund into custody and adjourned the case for sentencing on May 24.
During the trial, Lund explained that his wife, who suffered depression and had attempted suicide five times since the mid-1970s, was "complicated".
Although doctors had told the retired teacher that her bowel condition would improve within two years, she found the illness humiliating and restrictive.
He said that he initially refused her requests to help her to die but eventually succumbed in mid-August, shortly after they watched a television programme about euthanasia together.
He said: "I don't know why I felt differently.
"Perhaps it was the accumulation, but it did strike a chord with me that it was her choice.
"I went to bed and when I woke up it was absolutely clear in my mind."
Lund said he made a solemn vow' to his wife that she would die with dignity, in her own bed, on a day of her choosing, at their home in New Brighton, Merseyside.
He said he also promised she would not wake up in hospital.
She asked to die soon after Lund made the vow but he asked her to wait two more weeks, and on the morning of September 1 she said: "Today's the day. I want to do it today."
Lund told the jury: "I knew exactly what she meant because there was no other topic of conversation by then."
Lund explained that he went out to buy nearly 100 paracetamol tablets for his wife, along with roses and two farewell cards which he wrote from himself and their pets.
He said that Mrs Lund took the tablets without his help but she began vomiting and he was worried they would not kill her.
He asked if she wanted to go to hospital but she refused.
Andrew Menary QC, defending, asked if he considered taking her to hospital against her wishes. Lund replied: "That would have been equivalent to the greatest act of disloyalty and betrayal I could have rendered against her. I would have been better to just desert her than to do that."
He placed a plastic bag over his wife's head and smothered her with a pillow to kill her.
He then washed the body and changed her clothes and sheets before calling her two adult sons, whom he raised from a young age in Hebden Bridge, to explain what he had done.
The sons, Mr Olive and Daniel Olive-Lund, declined to comment outside court.
During the trial they spoke warmly of Lund and said he was devoted' to their mother.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article